Thursday, February 10, 2011

Book Reading #17: HCI Remixed

Chapter 6
Summary
Henry Lieberman writes about the paper “Pygmalion: A Creative Programming Environment” and the impact it had on him and computer science. Pygmalion, a graphical programming language, was one of the first systems to use icons and drag-and-drop. Lieberman also points out that it introduced the idea of programming by example. He also discusses how, thanks to D. C. Smith – the author of the paper – programming by example is one of Lieberman’s major areas of research. Lieberman also highlights some lessons provided by the paper: Don’t let the big questions scare you; think globally, act locally; hunt for the good stuff, even in out-of-the-way places; teach by example.

Discussion
Lieberman sounds very enthusiastic and appreciative of Smith’s work. I find it really interesting that Smith included so much information about creativity in his thesis, and as Lieberman pointed out, I don’t think it would be well accepted at HCI conferences now.

Chapter 7
Summary
Sara Bly writes about the Xerox Red Book and why it is important to her. She explains how the book had two main categories –  document creation and document management – and outlines three reasons why it is important to her:
1)    the interface was a primary concern
2)    they considered consistency and used it advantageously
3)    it offered a conceptual model
For her it acted as a guide for developing user interfaces and helped her better understand user interface design.

Discussion
I like the way Bly set up the chapter by first listing why it is important to her and then going into greater detail in three different labeled sections. I liked how she pointed out how consistency did not hinder them in their design process and how they managed to use it to their advantage. That’s not always easy to do.

Chapter 9
Summary
Norbert A. Streitz talks about the paper, “The Computer for the 21st Century.” The paper describes how the computer will be so integrated into our society in the 21st century that it will disappear. When Streitz read this paper, it resonated with him, and after seeing and using one of the first ubiquitous computers, he decided to continue the research in that area. He discusses the different steps he took in his research and two forms of disappearance: physical and mental.

Discussion
I’ve got to say that M. Weiser, the author of the paper, was pretty spot-on. I’d say the computer is pretty integrated into our lives. We don’t exactly have computers built into our walls and tables yet, but we definitely don’t look at all computers like computers anymore.
 
Chapter 10
Summary
Anind K. Dey writes about the paper, “The Active Badge Location System” and the first location-based system. In the Active Badge location system people could wear badges that allowed other people to locate them. It also allowed for the receptionists at the office to route phone calls to the phone nearest to the badge-wearer when a call came in for them. Dey praises the work, writing that it “arguably spawned the field of context-aware computing.”

Discussion
This paper describes more ways in which computers can be ubiquitous. The badge system was actually pretty neat. I’m not sure I’d like people being able to follow me everywhere I go at work, but then again I have usually stayed in my office/cubicle most of the time. This would probably be very beneficial in an environment where one moves around a lot.

Chapter 46
Summary
Kate Ehrlich discusses the book, The Psychology of Human-Computer Interaction, how influential the book was to her and the model people make in their minds of the computer system. Ehrlich explains how mental models helped developers design their systems and provided a theory of the user’s representation of the computer system. Ehrlich also discusses a particular model called GOMS (standing for goals, operators, methods and selectional rules).

Discussion
I found the last page where Ehrlich brings up some the controversy between psychologists, computer scientists, engineers and designers to be really interesting. I hadn’t considered how the blending that takes place within HCI could cause tension between the different fields. I also like the idea of the mental model. It helps us keep in mind the users that are not as knowledgeable about computers as we are.

Chapter 47
Summary
Gary M. Olson writes about the paper, “The Information Capacity of the Human Motor System in Controlling the Amplitude of Movement,” and how Paul M. Fitts, the author of the paper, had the goal of keeping the characteristics of human behavior in mind when designing equipment. Olson describes Fitts’s law, MT = a + b lg (2A/W) where MT = movement time, a and b are constants, A is the distance of the movement and W is the width of the target. As described in the paper, the law states that “the time it takes to move to a target is a function of the length of the movement and the size of the target. He notes this law because it has led to many interface innovations and because it is a quantitative law rather than qualitative, as many things in HCI are. Olson then outlines several design ideas that come from Fitts’s law.

Discussion
I found the point Olson raised near the beginning of the chapter about how HCI is greatly based on qualitative methods to be an interesting one. I hear and read a lot more about qualitative data than I do quantitative data in regards to HCI.

Ethnography Proposal - Final

You can find our final proposal on Paola's blog.

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

Paper Reading #7: Ben Neill and Bill Jones: Posthorn

Comments
 Evin Schuchardt- http://csce436spring2011.blogspot.com/2011/02/paper-reading-7-ben-neill-and-bill.html
- http://introductionblogassignment.blogspot.com/2011/02/paper-reading-7-robotany-breeze.html

Reference Information
Title: Ben Neill and Bill Jones: Posthorn
Authors: Ben Neill, Bill Jones
Presentation Venue: CHI 2010: 28th ACM Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems; April 10-15, 2010; Atlanta, GA, USA

Summary
This paper discusses an interactive computer system implemented on an instrument Ben Neill (one of the researchers) made called a mutantrumpet. The mutantrumpet is a combination of three trumpets and one trombone and some electronics that allow for MIDI control and conversion. The paper also describes three programs that respond to someone playing the instrument in real time.

The first program, called LiSa, is a sampling program that allows Neill to extract samples and modify them through several digital signal processing functions. The second program, Ableton Live, allows for Neill to process the output from LiSa as well as modify MIDI sequences from the mutantrumpet. The third program, Modul8, runs on a separate computer and translates the MIDI data into real time video.

The authors emphasize that with this system a person can vary a composition, allowing for more sounds and more images on the real time video.

mutantrumpet
Discussion
For me this paper was a little harder to follow. At times they just seemed to be going on and on without really saying anything. I believe I followed the general idea but the paper kept saying how the different parts of the mutantrumpet “enable Neill to” do this or do that. It didn’t really explain how any of it would be done by someone who didn’t know how to work it and it didn’t really say how the different parts did anything aside from saying that it used a function or used some other program.

As far as future works go, I’d say they might need to make this more user friendly though it might already be. I’m not really sure. I thought the different videos it created were kind of interesting so they could improve upon that or they could make a similar prototype that works on a normal instrument rather than some hybrid one that only one person knows how to work.

Book Reading #16: Opening Skinner's Box

Chapter 4
Summary
This chapter discusses the bystander effect and the phenomenon of diffusion of responsibility. It tells the story of Kitty Genovese and then explains the studies that followed by Darley and Latane. One particular study they did was interview college students. One student (the subject) sat in a room while all the others were prerecorded. Each student could only speak when it was their turn. One of the prerecorded students had a seizure, and Darley and Latane waited to see what the actual student will do. Thirty-one percent reacted when they thought there were other students hearing the same thing. However, eighty-five of students who thought they were alone with the one having the seizure sought help within the first three minutes.

Discussion
Like most of these chapters so far, we discussed this in my psychology class last semester. Another example of the bystander effect occurred at a bar in which a girl was sexually assaulted in front of everyone at the bar and no one did anything to stop it from happening. The girl called the police and a taxi on her own after everything was over with.

The author mentions that we need to be educated on this when we learn things like CPR and first aid. My mom is a Red Cross instructor and while she doesn’t mention the “bystander effect,” she does go into it in much fewer words and helps to train people to take charge and give orders like “you call 911” or “you help me turn him over.” People don’t often know what to do in these circumstances and they look to others to see what they’re doing. If everyone is doing nothing, then they will do nothing too unless given an order.

Monday, February 7, 2011

Book Reading #15: Coming of Age in Samoa

Chapter 5
Summary
In chapter 5 Mead discusses the different groups of friends a girl has as she ages. When the girls get to the age of about seven, the girls make friends outside of their family. The friends come from both relationship and neighborhood groups. No intense friendships are made at this age.

Mead gives several examples of girls who interacted differently with these groups. One girl, Luna, tended to stay closer to her aunt and grandmother. A different girl, Vina, was always the “little girl” of the group, because she followed a group of older girls around.

When the girls reach the age of sixteen or seventeen their group of friends still relies on relatives but is limited to smaller groups of two or three. Proximity does not play a role in the selection of friends at this point. Instead, relationships and similar sex interests plays a role.

Mead also spends a little time discussing the groups of friends the boys have. Young boys follow the same social pattern as the young girls. However, the sixteen and seventeen year old boys gang together just as they do in the younger age group. The boys also have two special relationships that form between two boys both called the soa.

The author also notes that grouping is influenced in many cases by rank and prospective rank as well.

Discussion
This chapter was a bit denser than the others. There was a lot to take in about the social workings of their groups and the times at which the groups change. In ways it sounds very different from groups of friends here. At the ages described here I had several different groups of friends all at once: the school group, neighborhood group, the common interests group, and the family group.

Book Reading #14: Design of Everyday Things

Chapter 5
Summary
This chapter breaks down human errors into two main categories, slips and mistakes, and then breaks the category of slip down further into the following categories: capture errors, description errors, data-driven errors, associative activation errors, loss-of-activation errors and mode errors.

Norman also discusses how to detect slips and then relates slips to the design process to improve design. He then presents the idea of wide, deep, shallow and narrow structures in relation to tasks and provides some examples.

In several sections of the chapter Norman discusses the human mind, focusing on human thought and the different behaviors of the conscious and subconscious.

At the end of the chapter he relates his different explanations on errors and the thought process to the design process and the use of forcing functions, a kind of constraint that makes it so that a failure at one stage prevents the user from moving on to the next stage. With several examples he highlights the importance of minimizing the nuisance value while retaining the safety value.

Discussion
As with the other chapters, I found myself nodding as I read through the different types of slips and the different examples presented throughout the chapter. I especially liked the section that linked mistakes to social pressure. It is something I would not have thought of initially that can actually play a big role in making mistakes out in the field.

Sunday, February 6, 2011

Ethnography Results – Week 1 - Trial - Mall Kiosks

Blue box: less crowds Red Box: more crowds
I spent 2 hours switching back and forth between observing two different vendors.

Quantitative Results
Female vendor at kiosk selling skin care products:
2 attempts to engage shopper in which she got their attention but they declined
2 attempts to engage shopper in which shopper ignored her
Total vendor sales: 0

 
Male vendor manning three kiosks:
Sunglasses kiosk:
0 attempts to engage shoppers but 7 successful sales
1 sale lost since he was busy with other customers
7 successful sales
Hair styling product kiosk:
10-12 attempts to engage shopper in which he got their attention but they declined
5 attempts to engage shopper in which shopper ignored him
2 successful sales
Shirt kiosk:
0 attempts
1 possible sale failed since he was busy with other kiosk so shopper left
1 successful sale
Total vendor sales: 10

Qualitative Results
Since I wasn’t sure if there was a specific format for this, I decided to give this a little narrative flair.

After my time at the mall on Saturday watching vendors man their kiosks and make a few sales – or none at all – the first conclusion I came to was that these vendors are not as lively as the ones in Houston, which left me a little disappointed.

While many of the vendors sat in their chairs with their eyes glued to the screen of their computers or their ears glued to their cell phones, I spotted one vendor walking back and forth behind her kiosk showcasing salts and skin care products. It was situated down the way from Macy’s. This part of the mall did not contain the swarms of people that seemed to congregate only closer to the food court or down by Auntie Anne’s pretzel shop. The vendor had her work cut out for her.

As groups of people pass by, likely drawn to the area by a car on display back behind the kiosk, the vendor looks to each shopper’s eyes in search of anyone willing to make eye contact. Meanwhile the shoppers keep their eyes straight ahead, likely glued to that shiny new car. Suddenly the vendor catches a customer’s eye, and the vendor attempts to initiate. She holds up her hands as if reciting a prayer and utters several words I cannot hear. The shopper turns away as if suddenly enthralled by the blank wall to her right.

The vendor’s jaw snaps shut and she begins to search again. She walks back and forth behind her kiosk never quite making it to the front side. Whether she does this to give potential buyers a better view of the kiosk or does this as a way to hide behind the tall cart, I am not sure. All I do know is that she is trying much harder than the majority of the vendors who never make eye contact and never make any attempt to initiate. (I did not spend any time on this trial run observing the vendors doing nothing.)

The vendor appears to get frustrated. She calls someone on her cell phone, but the conversation is short. Twice while I watch her from a bench feigning interest in a videogame my fiancĂ© is playing while I observe the vendor and take notes, the vendor leaves her kiosk unattended only to come back several minutes later. While she’s gone I notice that shoppers pass more closely by the kiosk and pass even in the small space between it and the shiny new car.

Curious when the vendor leaves a third time, I follow her and discover she’s friends with the only other lively vendor I’ve seen in the mall today. He wears a scarf, wields a brown comb and appears to be manning three kiosks at once. The girl does not stay with him long. They exchange a few words – possibly words of encouragement because the girl appears pretty ran down by this point – and then she heads back.

I stand by to observe the guy with the scarf. He mans one kiosk laden with hair straighteners and curlers, another with sunglasses and another with shirts all side by side. I learn quite quickly that the sunglasses kiosk is the happening place.

“Curly tired to initiate,” my fiancĂ© reports, alluding to a guy with brown curly hair, as I scribble down some notes. “Blondy stands waiting with him.” Blondy and Curly remain for a moment, then leave, losing interest since the vendor is talking to two other shoppers.

This vendor seems to have an easier time at least with the sunglasses kiosk. For several minutes shopper after shopper approaches him about the sunglasses and picks out a pair. When the crowd thins, he returns to the kiosk with hair styling products. He’s quicker to greet people, and here the halls seem narrower and more crowded, making it harder for a shopper to ignore him. It’s also much closer to the food court. The vendor also seems to be screening his shoppers, targeting the women and girls with glossy straight hair or carefully styled curly hair.

He waves the comb at a few shoppers. Some merely shake their head and move on while others stop to listen to him. Very few, about five out of the twelve or so shoppers I saw him initiate with, flat out ignore him. One girl seems to take a great interest in a hair straightener after he waves her down. However, once he pats a black hair resembling the ones found in salons, the shopper shakes her head and continues on.

During this particular event a couple of people gather at the third kiosk with shirts. He quickly makes a sale and returns to the first kiosk. A couple of times the vendor gets on a white phone attached to the kiosk. A few minutes and several sunglasses sales later, a new vendor appears and takes over at the sunglasses kiosk, giving the vendor with the scarf and brown comb more time to focus on the hair styling products kiosk which he does. (I rarely ever saw him at the shirt kiosk nor did I see shoppers there.)

Meanwhile, the female vendor who hasn’t had much luck with her kiosk continues to search for eye contact. The short phone calls on her cell phone or the phone attached to the kiosk increase – one call per every five minutes to a call every one or two minutes. The calls are short and in between those times, the vendor walks behind her kiosk. Once she approaches a shopper with her hands palm down in front of herself to ask the shopper to show her her nails. The shopper complies and for an instant the vendor’s shoulders lift with this possible sale. Then the shopper glances towards the kiosk and shakes her head.

The crowds are thinning around both vendors I’m watching, so I decide to make one last pass by them. I’m surprised to find them both on the phone, the white one attached to their kiosks, and after what I’ve seen I believe they might have been on the phone with each other, but I am not certain.

Conclusion
Based on everything I watched, I am uncertain how so many of the kiosks stay in business. The vendor with the scarf made plenty of sales, but the female vendor made none that I saw even with the effort she was making. The other couple of vendors I watched less closely made no efforts and as a result made no sales.

After this trial observation, I am not sure whether it would be worthwhile to continue or not. On the one side, I did pick up on a couple of different techniques that the vendors used and an interesting relationship between some of the vendors I would not have noticed otherwise. However, many of the vendors did nothing but sit. Only two appeared actively working while a select other few stood staring at their computers rather than sat. Coming at a few other parts of the day or on a few different days may yield better results but it all depends on the vendors.