Wednesday, February 16, 2011

Book Reading #21: Design of Everyday Things

Chapter 7
Summary
This final chapter in some ways summarizes the book as a whole. It discusses seven principles for transforming difficult tasks into simple tasks, reminds the readers of models and mapping and discusses constraints. Norman also writes about standardizing design when something cannot be designed without difficulties and how certain things actually need to be designed to be difficult. Norman also discusses automation and writes about the gradual automation of both the different styles and tools used over the years in writing.

Discussion
Something that confused me in this chapter was the mention of POET in the first sentence and throughout this final chapter. Perhaps I just never noticed it anywhere else or maybe it actually wasn’t mentioned before this chapter, but it threw me off for the first few pages of chapter 7 until I realized he was referring to the old title of this book.

I think the part I found most interesting about this chapter was the section about how doors at a school for handicapped children have the latches at the very top of the door to prevent children from going outside alone. While I think it could be dangerous in certain circumstances (and I’m not sure I’d be tall enough to reach the latch), it is interesting that this design was proposed and accepted.

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

Paper Reading #9: EverybodyLovesSketch: 3D sketching for a broader audience

Comments
Pape Youm - http://436chi-lounge.blogspot.com/2011/02/paper-reading-9-everybodylovessketch-3d.html
Alyssa Nabors - http://csce436-nabors.blogspot.com/2011/02/reading-9-improved-window-switching.html

Reference Information
Title: EverybodyLovesSketch: 3D sketching for a broader audience
Authors: Seok-Hyung Bae, Ravin Balakrishnan, Karan Singh
Presentation Venue: UIST 2010: 22nd annual ACM symposium on User interface software and technology; October 4-7, 2009; Victoria, British Columbia, Canada

Summary
This paper is about several researchers’ effort to develop a tool that helps untrained people practice and perfect their drawing skills through a 3D curve sketching system called EverybodyLovesSketch.

The paper gives a system overview in which the researchers explain the different curves and sketch surfaces in detail. They then present a user study in which 49 high school students used EverybodyLovesSketch in a 75 minute design class for 11 days. They broke the students into three groups with one group doing freeform architectural design, another car design and the last doing whatever they like including drawing cartoon characters.

Their results proved that the system is highly learnable. They found that 78% of the students doing architectural design and 90% of the students drawing the car had completed meaningful 3D models within the first two days. The third group, drawing cartoons, were found to be slightly slower because they started out by drawing 2D characters.

By the last day of the study 47 out of 49 students had successfully created 3D objects. The study also suggested that the program improved the students’ spatial and perspective drawing skills, but they believe more studies are needed to further evaluate this potential benefit.

Student drawings taken from the paper
Discussion
Though I felt a little bogged down in the middle of the paper when they were describing the more technical aspects of the system, this paper was very interesting and I was glad to see a rather in-depth user study performed. I was once really into drawing, but as the authors describe in the paper, I felt I had reached my highest potential and that it just wasn’t very good so I gave it up. Maybe having a system like this would have kept me motivated.

They mention more studies need to be done to better evaluate certain things like the potential for this system to improve one’s drawing skills on paper. They also discuss how a certain feature was rated low because the students didn’t use it and it would occasionally turn on when they meant to do something else. After fixing bugs such as these, I think they could do several more user studies to improve their system and explore the benefits to the system.

Monday, February 14, 2011

Book Reading #20: Opening Skinner's Box

Chapter 5
Summary
This chapter discusses Leon Festinger’s theory of cognitive dissonance. Slater describes some of Festinger’s experiments including his observation of those who believed a flood would come on December 21, 1954 and an experiment involving having people lie for either $1 or $20. A large portion of the chapter focuses on mother named Linda Santo whose daughter she claims to be a saint that God has chosen to be a victim soul that takes on the pain of others. Her observations and interviews with Linda Santo bring up more questions about cognitive dissonance.

Discussion
The lines defined in this chapter are a little fuzzier than the lines drawn in other chapters. Slater presents a really interesting topic and manages to raise more questions about it by the end of the chapter. Near the end she raises the question, “Did Festinger ever consider how our justifications are to save not only ourselves, but others too?” This is a good question, and I think there are a lot more experiments that could be done that might help us to better understand the theory of cognitive dissonance.

Sunday, February 13, 2011

Book Reading #19: Coming of Age in Samoa

Chapter 6
Summary
This chapter focuses on the role girls play in the community. The organization of young men is called the Aumaga, and the organization of young girls, wives of untitled men and the widows is called the Aualuma. The Aumaga is a lot like the organization of older men. They do the heavy work of the village and play a great part in the social intercourse between villages. The Aualuma is less formalized, and they do “hardly any work.” Their main function is to be village hostesses  and ceremonial helpers at certain meetings for the wives of matais.

The chapter also discusses the women’s fonos of which there are two kinds: the ones that follow or precede communal work and the ceremonial fonos. Mead also mentions several taboos and explains how relationship group matters are different from the group matters already described.

Discussion
I’m not sure if it’s just because I’m use to our culture or not, but the formation of their groups sounds very complex and the different roles they play and rules they follow also sound complex.

I think it’s interesting how talking chiefs and chiefs must be spoken to with a different set of verbs and nouns suitable to his rank. It reminds me of the Japanese with the formal and informal speech – one thing that makes the language more difficult to learn. I wonder if Mead had to follow these rules too (as I’m sure she did), and if she ever messed up. When I took Japanese and had to carry on a conversation with my professor's Japanese wife, I was really nervous about insulting her by conjugating a verb in the informal rather than formal form.

Book Reading #18: Design of Everyday Things

Chapter 6
Summary
Chapter 6 focused on the different challenges a designer faces when designing a new product. He discussed how certain negative forces like the demands of time and the pressure to be distinctive work against evolutionary design. Norman also outlined the history of the typewriter and the design difficulties of the faucet. He outlined the different reasons why designers go astray: they put aesthetics first, they are not typical users and they’re clients may not be users. He also discussed creeping featurism and the worshiping of complexity, two temptations designers face. Norman concluded by relating the design issues discussed to computers.

Discussion
My favorite part of the chapter was the discussion of the history of the typewriter and the discussion on the faucet designs. I think we’ve all encountered a few faucets in our day that were designed poorly and left us with soapy hands or burned our fingers.

Saturday, February 12, 2011

Ethnography Results - Week 2

Ethnography Results Week 2
Sweet Eugene’s House of Java

Friday February 11, 2011
5:00-7:00pm

Quantitative
7 people appearing over the age of 30 were there at some point. The rest were younger looking.
Totals for the evening:
Order drink to go: 4
On Computer: 12
Reading book/ doing homework: 20 (defined as having book and/or spiral and pencil)
Working with computer and book: 4
Visiting: 14
Main goal to eat: 3 (these people read a book or used their computer until food arrived. Then they at and left)

Collected times for people who left (x means I don’t know when they arrived):
X – 5:25 (3 girls talking)
X – 5:34 (older group talking)
5:14 – 5:34 (couple talking)
5:44 – 6:28 (2 guys eating)
X – 6:01 (girl on computer)
X – 6:10 (guy on computer at the counter)
X – 6:42 (on computer)
5:52 – 6:49 (book)
X – 6:55 (computer)
X – X (couple talking)
X – X (computer and book)
(A lot of other people came in during the time I was there and never left.)

Qualitative 
My location
Near the center of the large room, allowing for a view of everyone in the large room that was in front of me and limited view (don’t want to look too obvious) of the area behind me. I also had partial view of the smaller room where the couches were.

The Employees
Upon arriving, my fiancĂ©, Jesse, and I went straight to the counter to order. When I asked what was in the Iced Chai, the employee made a point about the secretiveness of the business. He also admitted that he did not like tea so he couldn’t really tell us whether it was good or not. I ordered the iced mocha.
A blond employee came over while the other made my drink. Jesse asked them to whip him up whatever was good. The blond asked, “Do you like oreos?” The other, already done making my drink, said, “You do today.”

A different employee came to clean some of the tables that were left dirty. She didn’t bother anyone who appears to have empty mugs on their table.

The customers
To clean or not to clean
Of all the people I saw, three groups were made of people over the age of thirty. All those groups left their tables dirty while everyone else put their cups where on a tray at the counter to be cleaned. Whether this is due to negligence or just not knowing what to do, only time will tell.

Popular tables

4 tables that were occupied by one person or group were occupied by a different person or group by the time we left, leading me to believe that these tables are popular though I’m uncertain why. 3 of the tables were up against walls while the last was out in the open.

One purchase or multiple?
Of everyone I saw, only one girl appeared to have gone back multiple times. She had 2 coffee cups and a plate with a half-eaten muffin on it.

Enjoy the environment or shut it out?
I noticed one person using headphones for much of his time at Sweet Eugene’s.

Trusting customers
I noted at least eight customers put their bags and computers down and leave them unattended for 5+ minutes to go order or take a phone call or use the bathroom

Searching for seclusion
Focusing only on the people in front of me (about 10-15 depending on when), about ½ of the groups took to tables or seats that did not have someone right beside them. One girl walking with two other people asked as she passed, “Where do you want to sit?” A guy in the group replied, “Preferably away from people.”

Sticking around for a long time
One guy who had been at Eugene’s since I arrived moved his computer from one table to another that was beside a wall to plug in his computer. This happened an hour into my visit and tells me he had been there for a long time. He left a few minutes before I did.

Three other people stuck around the entire time we were there. One appeared to be doing homework and had only one mug on her table. She had a computer and books. The other two sat at a table next to a window and talked the whole time. Jesse and I left before they did.
From Sweet Eugene's Facebook Page

Friday, February 11, 2011

Paper Reading #8: Shadows no. 4: belly dance and interactive electroacoustic musical performance

Comments
Evin Schuchardt - http://csce436spring2011.blogspot.com/2011/02/paper-reading-8-shadows-no-4-belly.html
Vince Kocks - http://vincehci.blogspot.com/2011/02/paper-reading-8-exploring-mobile.html

Reference Information
Title: Shadows no. 4: belly dance and interactive electroacoustic musical performance
Authors: Aurie Y. Hsu, Steven T. Kemper
Presentation Venue: CHI 2010: 28th ACM Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems; April 10-15, 2010; Atlanta, GA, USA

Summary
This paper discusses how the two authors developed an interactive system that incorporates both movement and music. For their research they have a belly dancer perform while wearing sensors that capture the dancer’s motions and produce music.


Image taken from the video of the performance at the conference
Their system is made up of a 2-inch diameter disc called LilyPad Arduino sewn to the fabric with insulated wire. As the dancer performs, the LilyPad takes in the motion data through different sensors and wirelessly sends it to a computer as serial data. The computer processes the data through a visual programming environment called Max, which maps the data to audio processing control parameters such as harmonization and playback speed. 

Discussion
First, a video performance from the conference can be found here: http://www.chi2010.org/attending/video/file184-3.mov

After watching the video, I have to say this is actually pretty neat, like orchestrating your own music through dancing. I also like the fact that they found a way to hide the sensor without degrading its performance. The authors also included some information about their earlier tests with a conductive thread that broke or shorted out when used to sew the disc to the clothing.

All in all the paper was an interesting one, but a little short. As for future work, they mention their plans to improve the sensor network further and incorporate other sensors like motion capture and biosensors to add further interaction. I’m kind of curious to see if they can make several systems that would work in harmony so that several dancers could perform together and make more complex-sounding music.